Read answers to your top agronomic questions. Download the 2023 Product Agronomy Research (PAR) Report HERE.

Back to Articles

Product and Agronomy Research (PAR) Results: Fungicide Use For Increased Silage Quantity & Quality

BY Dairyland Seed Agronomy Team
FUNGICIDE USE FOR INCREASED SILAGE QUANTITY & QUALITY

Description:

Concern over corn foliar diseases has increased in recent growing seasons. This is especially true when we account for concerns over tar spot. In this second-year research project we will focus on corn silage production.  We will be evaluating silage yield and silage quality. To achieve this, we looked at three categories of silage hybrids. Those hybrids are as follows: one HiDF - HiDF-5000Q™, one brown mid rib - DB-5211AMXT™ and one dual purpose - DS-5279Q™. They will all be treated with Approach® Prima fungicide at the label recommended timing of VT – R2.  The hybrids were planted at 33,600 seeds per acre and managed at standard agronomic levels. Each year we used four replications. Data assimilated were hand harvested silage weights, machine harvest grain yield as well as visual leaf ratings. In addition, all samples were submitted for silage quality analysis.

Results:

2021 Silage Corn Fungicide Trial

PRODUCT

TONS/A

STARCH

NDFD

 

TONS/A

STARCH

NDFD

 

NO FUNGICIDE

 

FUNGICIDE

BMR-3508RA™

25.1

37.7

58.5

 

24.8

39.0

60.4

HiDF-4999Q™

25.2

38.4

55.8

 

28.4

40.1

57.7

DS-5279Q™

31.1

38.4

56.2

 

30.1

39.0

56.5

Average

27.1

38.2

56.8

 

27.8

39.4

58.2

 

PRODUCT

GLS %

NCLB%

TAR SPOT%

 

GLS %

NCLB%

TAR SPOT%

 

NO FUNGICIDE

 

FUNGICIDE

BMR-3508RA™

7.5

1.5

0.0

 

17.5

5.0

0.25

HiDF-4999Q™

5.0

0.0

0.5

 

1.0

0.0

0.25

DS-5279Q™

6.5

0.0

0.0

 

2.0

0.5

0.25

 

Wabash 2022

PRODUCT

TONS/A

STARCH

NDFD

 

TONS/A

STARCH

NDFD

 

NO FUNGICIDE

 

FUNGICIDE

HiDF-5000Q™

29.54

34.27

54.43

 

30.45

31.57

53.67

DS-5279Q™

29.54

37.30

58.07

 

31.85

36.94

56.80

DB-5211AMXT™

27.91

31.70

58.28

 

26.18

31.29

61.42

Average

28.99

34.42

56.93

 

29.49

33.27

57.30

 

2021 and 2022 Averages

 

TONS/A

STARCH

NDFD

 

TONS/A

STARCH

NDFD

 

NO FUNGICIDE

 

FUNGICIDE

2022 Avg

28.99

34.42

56.93

 

29.49

33.27

57.30

2021 Avg

27.12

38.17

56.82

 

27.77

39.36

58.23

Two years

28.06

36.29

56.87

 

28.63

36.31

57.76

Conclusion:

Limited disease levels in both 2021 and 2022 may have reduced the impact of fungicide applications. In 2021, disease ratings were taken and are reported above. In 2022, disease ratings were taken but little to no disease was present at the late August rating date. Both years we looked for gray leaf spot, northern corn leaf blight and tar spot. In both years we have noticed that tar spot infestations increased significantly in the month of September. This, as we have come to observe, has been rather typical of this disease. In 2021, we observed increased tonnage of about 1,400 lbs (.7 ton) and in 2022, it was slightly less at 1,000 lbs  (.5 ton). Starch data for the two years was mixed, with 2021 showing a slight advantage to fungicide and starch content and 2022 showing a bit of a decrease with fungicide applications. The NDFD30 numbers showed an increase for both years. However, again for 2022, the difference was not as great as in 2021. Two-year averages show a .57 ton advantage for fungicide applications and .89 increase in NDFD30. Starch numbers for the two years was negligible. Summarizing, even under little to no disease pressure we are recording an advantage to applying fungicide for corn silage production. It looks as if both years, the increased tonnage will cover the cost of fungicide application. The gain (or profit) would be in “feed hygiene” and increased NDFD30 and quality.


Brian Weller Dan Ritter Branden Furseth Mark Gibson Amanda Goffnett
Brian Weller
Western Region
507.456.3034
Dan Ritter
Central Region
219.863.0583
Branden Furseth
Northern Region
608.513.4265
Mark Gibson
Eastern Region
260.330.8968
Amanda Goffnett
Eastern Region
989.400.3793
Enjoying our Agronomy Updates? Suggestions for topics you'd like us to weigh in on? Drop us an email at dairylandseed@dairylandseed.com. We'd love to hear from you!

 

Subscribe for more insights delivered straight to your inbox.
You may also like...
  • Soybean Germination and Early Growth Refresher
    Soybeans, much like corn, need to imbibe (take in) water for the germination process to take place. The difference is that soybeans need to take in 50 percent of its weight in water to start this process compared to 30 percent for corn. Since soybeans are about two-thirds the weight of corn, the actual amount of water needed to germinate is very similar.
    Read more
  • Growing Degree Unit Compression
    The extended cool and wet weather has kept many of us out of the fields and has raised concerns about planting delays, especially if replants are needed. A common question among growers is whether they should consider switching some of their full-season hybrids to shorter-maturity hybrids, and if so, how soon? The short answer to that question is no, it’s still a little early to consider switching hybrids. Although delayed planting shortens the growing season, the main driver is still growing degree units (GDUs) for the plant to reach physiological maturity before a killing frost.
    Read more
  • Proud Sponsor of this Year’s Popular “Here We Grow” Project
    This season, Dairyland Seed—and our very own Trygve Skolness—are partnering with Weather & Ag in Focus, WDAY radio’s weekday show, on their highly regarded “Here We Grow” project.
    Read more
Find Your Rep